Table of Contents
Taking leave to care for a new baby, recover from surgery, or help a family member through a serious illness should not put a job in jeopardy. Yet employers routinely deny leave requests, punish workers for taking approved leave, or fail to restore them to their position afterward. As an FMLA lawyer representing employees in New York and New Jersey, our firm has seen how these violations disrupt income, health coverage, and careers at exactly the moment families can least afford it.
The Family and Medical Leave Act gives millions of workers a federal right to unpaid, job-protected leave, but the law is only as strong as its enforcement.
When an employer ignores that right, whether through outright denial, subtle discouragement, or retaliation after the fact, employees often do not realize they have a claim until the damage is done. We help clients identify the violation, understand their options, and decide on a path forward.
If you believe your employer violated your FMLA rights, the team at Dudani Law can review what happened and explain where you stand.
What Is FMLA and Who Is Eligible?
The FMLA does not apply to every worker or employer, so the first step is confirming eligibility. Employees qualify if they have worked for a covered employer for at least 12 months, logged at least 1,250 hours of service in the prior 12 months, and work at a location with at least 50 employees within 75 miles. An FMLA lawyer typically starts by confirming these facts, since employers sometimes misstate eligibility to justify a denial.
Qualifying Reasons for Leave
Eligible employees can take up to 12 workweeks of leave in a 12-month period for most qualifying reasons, and up to 26 workweeks for military caregiver leave. Common reasons include the birth or adoption of a child, a serious health condition affecting the employee, or caring for a spouse, child, or parent with a serious health condition. Leave can be taken all at once, intermittently, or on a reduced schedule, depending on medical need and certification.
The 12-Month Rule Is Not Always Consecutive
Many employees assume they need a full, unbroken year on the job before FMLA applies, but that is not accurate. The 12 months of employment do not need to be consecutive. This matters for workers who left and returned to the same employer or had a gap in service, since prior time on the job may still count.
Common FMLA Violations by Employers
Some employers flatly refuse a valid leave request, while others pressure employees to delay, shorten, or withdraw it. Discouragement can include questioning a medical condition, suggesting leave will hurt a performance review, or making the process so difficult that an employee gives up. Either approach can expose an employer to liability, since the law protects the right to take leave, not just the paperwork around it.
Mishandling Leave Tied to Pregnancy or a New Child
Leave denials around childbirth, adoption, or related complications often overlap with other legal protections. Our pregnancy discrimination practice regularly intersects with FMLA claims, since an employer that denies leave to a pregnant employee or penalizes her for taking it may violate both the FMLA and anti-discrimination law at once. Identifying every applicable claim matters because it can affect available remedies and deadlines.
Misclassifying Employees as Ineligible
A frequent violation involves an employer incorrectly telling an employee they do not qualify, often by miscounting hours, misstating company size, or ignoring prior employment that should count toward the 12-month threshold. Because eligibility rules are technical, an employer’s assertion of ineligibility is not always correct. An FMLA violation lawyer can recalculate eligibility independently rather than accepting an employer’s say-so.
FMLA Interference vs. FMLA Retaliation: Two Distinct Claims
Interference claims arise when an employer denies a benefit the employee was actually entitled to receive. The Act’s prohibition against interference bars an employer from discriminating or retaliating against an employee for having exercised or attempted to exercise FMLA rights. This includes refusing qualifying leave, failing to restore an employee afterward, or manipulating duties to defeat eligibility.
What Counts as Retaliation
Retaliation punishes an employee for using or asserting FMLA rights rather than simply denying the underlying benefit. The FMLA prohibits using leave as a negative factor in hiring, promotion, or discipline decisions, and it cannot be counted against an employee under no-fault attendance policies. A demotion, a sudden negative review, or a termination following closely after leave can all signal retaliation, especially when the employer’s stated reason does not hold up.
Why the Distinction Matters for Your Case
Courts and agencies treat these two theories differently, which affects what evidence matters and how a claim gets built. An FMLA retaliation lawyer looking at a termination needs to examine timing, comparisons to similarly situated coworkers, and whether the employer’s explanation changed over time. A denial of leave for a serious health condition can also raise ADA concerns, which is why our disability discrimination practice often works alongside FMLA claims.
How FMLA Interacts With New York Paid Family Leave
New York’s Paid Family Leave program and the federal FMLA both protect time off for family and medical reasons, but they are not identical. You can read the details on the 2026 Paid Family Leave updates page. Unlike the unpaid FMLA, PFL provides wage replacement funded through employee payroll contributions.
Running Leave Concurrently
When an employee qualifies for both programs, employers generally run FMLA and PFL concurrently rather than stacking them into separate leave periods. This matters because an employee who exhausts PFL benefits may still have FMLA job protection in effect, or vice versa, depending on how the employer tracks the two. Confusion about which law applies, or an employer’s failure to designate leave correctly, is a frequent source of disputes we see.
Protections that Carry Across Both Laws
New York’s program backs its paid benefit with job security similar to the federal law. Employees have job protection, ensuring they can return to the same job (or a comparable one) when they return from Paid Family Leave, can keep their health insurance while on leave on the same terms they had while working, and employers are prohibited from discriminating or retaliating against employees for requesting or taking Paid Family Leave.
An employee who experiences retaliation after PFL leave may have overlapping claims under both state and federal law, broadening the available remedies.
Job Restoration and Health Insurance Rights During Leave
The FMLA’s job restoration guarantee is one of its most important protections. Employees must be restored to the same or virtually identical position upon return, meaning equivalent pay, benefits, and working conditions, not necessarily the same desk or title. An employer offering a lesser role or stalling the return date without justification may be in violation.
Continued Health Coverage While on Leave
Employees do not lose group health benefits simply because they are on leave. The employer must maintain coverage on the same terms as if the employee had continued working, and the employee generally remains responsible only for their usual share of the premium. Gaps in coverage, surprise premium demands, or terminated coverage during approved leave are red flags worth raising with a lawyer.
When Restoration Rights Don’t Apply
Job restoration is not absolute. An employer can sometimes show that a position would have been eliminated regardless of the leave, such as during a broader layoff unrelated to the absence. These cases often turn on timing and documentation, which is why a termination following closely after FMLA leave deserves careful review, something our wrongful termination practice evaluates alongside any FMLA claim.
What to Do if Your FMLA Rights Were Violated
Save leave requests, medical certifications, emails with HR, and paperwork related to your leave or return date. Write down conversations where a supervisor discouraged leave, questioned your condition, or hinted at consequences for taking time off. This record becomes the backbone of any later claim, since memory fades and employers control most of the official file.
Understand the Deadlines You’re Working Against
FMLA claims are subject to specific filing deadlines, and waiting too long can mean losing the right to pursue a claim regardless of how strong the facts are. Deadlines can also differ depending on whether a claim involves interference, retaliation, or an overlapping state law theory like Paid Family Leave. Because these timelines run whether or not you’ve consulted anyone, it makes sense to talk to a lawyer promptly.
Talk to a Lawyer Before Accepting an Employer’s Explanation
Employers rarely announce that they are violating the FMLA. Instead, they offer reasons- a reorganization, a performance issue, a policy change- that may or may not hold up once examined. A lawyer for FMLA violations can request the right documents, compare your treatment to coworkers, and determine whether the employer’s story matches what actually happened.
Frequently Asked Questions
Yes. The New Jersey Family Leave Act covers employers with 30 or more employees and allows up to 12 weeks of job-protected leave in a 24-month period to bond with a new child or care for a family member with a serious health condition. It doesn’t cover your own medical condition, which remains under the FMLA.
New Jersey also offers wage replacement through its Family Leave Insurance program, so New Jersey workers may have more protection than the federal law alone provides.
Yes, in some situations. Employees do not always need to use the words “FMLA leave” when asking for time off; giving an employer enough information to understand the leave may qualify as sufficient. Whether that happened in your situation depends on the specific conversations and paperwork involved.
Generally, you have two years from the date of the violation to file an FMLA lawsuit, or three years if the employer’s violation was willful. A claim can be filed directly in court, so there’s no requirement to file with a government agency first. Related claims under state law, such as disability or pregnancy discrimination, may have different and sometimes shorter deadlines, which is why it helps to have every possible claim reviewed early.
It can. Multi-state employers, remote work arrangements, and companies with offices in both New York and New Jersey sometimes raise questions about which state’s additional leave laws apply on top of the federal FMLA. These situations usually require looking closely at where the employee actually works and where the employment relationship is based.
Contact an FMLA Attorney for a Free Case Evaluation
If you were denied leave you were entitled to, pressured to cut your leave short, or let go shortly after taking time off, you don’t have to sort out the next step alone. We represent employees across New York and New Jersey in FMLA interference and retaliation matters, and we can help you understand whether what happened to you violated the law. Reach out to Dudani Law to discuss your situation and learn what options may be available.





